US5 min(s) read
Published 09:23 24 Jul 2026 GMT
Chilling twist in case of New York grandmother who 'poisoned daughter and 4 grandchildren' in alleged murder-suicide
Police have not ruled out the involvement of Sarah Myers, a mom-of-four, in a murder-suicide case that left her, the children, and their grandmother dead in New York.
Investigators believe that there is a possibility that Myers, 44, was involved in the deaths of her children Harper, 13, Hudson, 11, and Gavin and Gracelynn, both 10, as well as her mother Amy Steadman, 64.
The bodies were found inside Steadman's apartment in Mechanicville, New York, on June 23.
One of the kids was found to have died as the result of a fatal "sharp injury," while other kids showed signs of being poisoned.
Earlier in the investigation, Police Chief William Rabbitt said that evidence "strongly suggests" that the children's grandmother was responsible for the horrific murders, with a handwritten note and bottles of prescription and medicines found in the home.
However, this week, Rabbitt told NBC 5: "We have not ruled out that Sarah Myers was also complicit in the deaths of her children."
Claims from the children's father
Following the police chief's claim, he didn't elaborate, instead highlighting that the case is still active and that there is "still a great deal to be said."
Investigators are yet to explain what happened in Steadman's apartment last month, as Rabitt further noted: "We are still awaiting final toxicology results and the completion of other forensic testing."
This update comes after a shocking revelation from the children's father, Brady Harmon, as he revealed that he received 10 letters from Saratoga County Child Protective Services.
They detailed that it was investigating the living conditions at his children's home, with the last letter stating that Myers was being investigated for Munchausen syndrome by proxy, as per the Albany Times-Union.
Munchausen syndrome, also known as factitious disorder imposed on self, is a mental health condition where an individual compulsively fakes, exaggerates, or intentionally causes illnesses and injuries in themselves, while Munchausen by proxy is when they inflict the same on their dependents.
Harmon said that a therapist found that Myers was negligent in caring for her kids, but they weren't in danger.
He even claimed that "nothing happened" after this, though he noticed that her apartment was a mess when he went to collect the children's belongings earlier this month, finding cat urine and feces.
The cat has been rescued since, and has also found a new home.
Harmon also admitted that he doesn't know who got in touch with Child Protective Services, believing that it may have been the officials at Mechanicville City School District.
This is because letters stopped coming in after Myers pulled the children out of the education system in 2024 to be homeschooled.
Lead-up to their deaths
Despite being separated from his kids since 2019, he kept in touch with them, reaching an agreement to have custody from July 1 to September 1.
He spoke with the kids on June 7, excited about their trip to Utah, but three days later, Myers texted him and said that they had fallen sick.
Harmon told the US Sun: "She messaged me, 'Hey, the kids are sick, we'll talk to you on the 11th.'"
The dad then called police to ask for welfare checks, as his lawyer sent Myers paperwork over an upcoming custody hearing on the 29th.
Steadman's neighbor, Stephanie Sweeney, also called authorities after she noticed several flies and a smell coming from the apartment.
This lead to the police making the horrific discovery of the bodies.
"I went from 'I'm seeing my kids' to 'I'll never see my kids again,'" the dad-of-four stated.
Harmon reflects on the situation
It's believed that Steadman resented Harmon for securing custody over the summer, as he suggested that his insistence on involving a lawyer may have sent the mom and grandmother "over the edge."
He suggested that they may have thought: "We don't know a way out of this, so let's do the next best thing. He'll never have access to these kids…"
This has not been confirmed.
Steadman's Facebook profile reveals that she shared a GoFundMe for her daughter to get a domestic violence lawyer back in 2022, though the fundraiser has since been deleted.
At the time, the grandma posted snaps of her daughter and children, captioning it: "Please help my daughter and grandchildren."
Harmon has denied the claims, calling Myers the "culprit," adding that she had once stabbed him in the face with a medicine dropper during a fight in 2019.
Now, the father has the children's cremated remains and flew them home for a funeral earlier this month, adding: "We could not bring their bodies home due to the horrific state they were in."
He spread their ashes at the same place his father's ashes were scattered, on top of a mountain, in a "devastating" turn of events for the dad.
"The only thing I can keep as a peace of mind is that my kids are safe in the arms of my father and other family members who loved them and not those who would hurt them," he admitted.
Harmon went on: "There is some relief, but there is a hole that could never be filled,
"I know at least I will eventually see them again."













