US3 min(s) read
Cheating husband told cops his wife died after falling while doing laundry before they checked his search history
Two years after the death of a Wisconsin woman, which was initially ruled accidental, her husband has been arrested after investigators discovered a series of alarming internet searches and proof of an affair.
Erica Carpenter, 40, was pronounced dead at the couple's home on October 13, 2024, after her husband claimed that his wife had died following a horrific accident on the stairs.
However, two years after the tragic death, an investigation has revealed that Benjamin Carpenter, 45, could be responsible, as authorities uncovered allegations of infidelity, a potentially suspicious substance in Erica’s drinking water, and a troubling search history in the hours leading up to her untimely death.
Benjamin did not alert emergency services immediately
On the night Erica died, emergency services were called to the family's home after receiving reports that a woman had fallen and was bleeding from the head. They found her with a "very blue" face and her husband desperately performing CPR.
Allegedly, Benjamin told officers that the couple had been doing laundry together when she collapsed and hit her head "mildly hard" on the floor, but rather than calling 911, he decided to carry his unconscious wife upstairs.
Then, he claimed he slipped on the staircase, sending them both flying and causing Erica to hit her head against a cinder block wall.
Alarmingly, investigators only began looking into Benjamin's personal life and behavior around the time of his wife's death when a witness came forward claiming he was having an affair last month.
The woman, identified as AMV, reportedly believed that Benjamin was going to divorce his wife on the weekend that she died. Cops were also informed that he had spent the night at AMV's house just days after the incident occurred.
It was more than just adultery that sparked suspicion over Benjamin's involvement
The plot thickened when law enforcement discovered that Benjamin had received between $220,000 and $230,000 from Erica’s life insurance policy.
Just days before her death, Erica had reportedly asked her husband about an unusual substance she found in her water, texting him: "What the f*** have you been doing to my water the past few days?!?!?"
Benjamin then lied, claiming that the "powdery s**t" was liquid IV. An autopsy later discovered that Erica had hydrocodone in her system, despite having no prescription for the medication.
However, her cause of death was ultimately listed as undetermined, but the medical examiner identified blunt-force injuries to her neck and petechial hemorrhaging, which are usually associated with asphyxiation.
In another concerning development, cops were called to the same house where Erica died less than a year later, following reports that Benjamin put his hand around the neck of AMV and strangled her.
Allegedly, the woman believed to be in a relationship with Benjamin following his wife's death told an Uber driver that if she died, it would be her partner who was responsible.
Benjamin is being held without bond at Milwaukee County Jail, where he was scheduled to make his initial court appearance yesterday.













